Drop us a line


Custom Orders

We offer custom, hand-painted, decorative sugar cookies to the Indianapolis area. Give us a call or fill out the form to let us know what you’re looking for, and we’ll do our best to make it happen! Cookies are made on a completely custom basis, and we always want to chat with you first to make sure your order is perfect.

Please submit all inquiries through the form to the right.

Lead Time & Pricing

We usually need two weeks notice to make sure we reserve time on our calendar to complete your order – sometimes more, sometimes less. Either way, it’s never too soon to get in touch!

Custom cookies usually range from $3-6 each, depending on intricacy of design, and pricing for other cookies can be found on our menu. We’re happy to work with you on options to fit your budget or your wildest dreams.

Pickup & Delivery

Custom orders can be picked up at Wildwood Market in Fountain Square (view map), or we can deliver within Indianapolis for a $15 delivery fee.

Where to buy

Lemon Tree Cookies doesn’t have our own storefront yet, but you can find our cookies around Indianapolis at a few select locations, including Fresco Italian Cafe on the Canal and Wildwood Market.

Follow us


People Love Us On Yelp

Order Form

Note: Our baker/decorator, Liz, is hard at work recovering from shoulder surgery, so we’re not able to take any orders right now. Thank you for understanding, and check back in later this summer!